- Brian Symons
- Mar 20, 2021
Author: Oliver Lang
Editor: Brian Symons

Spring training is in session, and most of the Mets team is decided, with potential all-stars at every position. But one still remains that is stirring up a decent amount of controversy—3rd base. The regular on the corner has been J.D. Davis, as he’s proven he can be an excellent hitter, slugging 22 homers in 2019 and batting .307 in 140 games. While his 2020 performance wasn’t quite as good, he is still a high-quality batter. The one problem with J.D. however, is his glove. While he isn’t the worst defender, he’s definitely not great. Throughout his career, he’s been a negative defense runs saved (DRS) player, which a team trying for a playoff run doesn’t want as a major liability on 3rd base.
On the other side of things is Luis Guillorme. Luis is a potential gold glove quality fielder— he has shown that constantly through the first years of his young career. Many people probably first heard of him from a past spring training when he caught a flying baseball bat as if it were nothing. The point is, he can field really well, and that’s something the Mets desperately need. In fact, Guillorme isn’t even bad at the plate. He just recently had the longest at-bat in baseball history (22 pitches), along with batting over .300 in 2020. However, there’s one problem—in that 2020 season, he didn’t hit a single homerun. He actually only has 1 homerun in his 109 career games. On 3rd base, you really need to have some level of power, and Luis doesn’t have that.
As each is strong in the category the other is weak in, you’d think that it’s a tie sort of situation between them, but that won’t particularly be true. Their skills aren’t the only big thing to factor in here.
The Mets pitching lineup is full of aces this season, including the best pitcher in baseball, Jacob deGrom. For someone like deGrom, who is likely to give up only 1 or 2 hits in most of his starts and strike out pretty much the rest of the batters, having a better bat to give run support is 100% more important, as there’s a good chance the 3rd baseman won’t even have to make a play all game. When deGrom is on the mound, J.D. should be in. On the other side of things, when someone a pitcher like Marcus Stroman, who gets more outs in play, should have the best defense possible, meaning that a top-notch defender like Luis should be in. What this is basically saying is there’s no one or the other— the answer is both. They should both go in the game— when their separate skill sets are most needed.
METS ARE OUR UNIVERSE